Automated bidding is a popular choice because it seems to promise fewer labor hours by letting an algorithm make your bid adjustments.

Sounds easy-peasy, right?

A set-it-and-forget-it approach that will make your life easier and shovel in all the leads and conversions you want.

It sounds too good to be true.

Automated Bidding is Not Always the Answer
Gif credit

That’s because it is. Automated campaigns can’t run unsupervised. 

Or, they can, but they won’t be successful and might waste your money if you or a PPC pro aren’t keeping a closer eye on them.

One thing we should note before going any further is that we typically do manual bidding for our clients since it allows more control, but occasionally we use automatic bidding if the client requests it or if a new feature has been introduced and we want to test it. Google is always updating and improving its automated bidding strategies, and we feel we’d be remiss if we didn’t try them.

So, we don’t ever not use automated bidding, but it isn’t a tactic we typically use or recommend.

And here’s why:

1. Algorithms are smart, but they aren’t smarter than humans

Algorithms can be narrow-minded in ways humans aren’t. Without regular maintenance, automated software will find a few targets that work really well and exclude everything else. 

And that’s fine on a limited budget, but it can lead to missing out on higher-value targets that could have a higher-quality of conversions. It might look like your PPC campaign is working well, but that doesn’t mean that it’s optimized. 

Consider your business’ goals first and foremost when choosing between manual and automated bidding. Maybe a campaign that is doing well is good enough for your business, or maybe you need to take more control.

2. To perform optimally, you need more data

Automated bidding probably isn’t the best place to start for a brand new account. If you don’t have at least a few months of data to draw from, the algorithm is just guessing as far as your bids are concerned. 

If you really want to use automated bidding, you should have someone handle the account personally at least at first to make sure the account is set up correctly, and the bids are optimized. 

Algorithms are only as smart as the data you give them, which is why the set-up process is so important.

3. You can’t selectively choose to increase bids on core terms

Just because you’re bidding on a particular keyword doesn’t mean that you’re showing up every time it’s searched. You could be showing up less than 10% of the time, and that could be because of low Ad Rank.

Often the quickest way to improve your rank is increasing your bid. But if you’re using automatic bidding, you can’t selectively choose to increase the bids on terms that are core to your company. 

There are going to be terms that are stronger for your product or service, and with manual bidding, you can increase the bids on those more important keywords to maximize conversions.

With automatic bidding, you’ll continue to lose potential conversions on those keywords.

4. Bids will keep rising if you don’t set a ceiling

You could end up with a higher cost per click (CPC) with automatic bidding. You might pay $50 for a click that could have been $10 with a manual bidding strategy. 

It’s like playing poker and raising your bet every single hand. You might win a few hands, but it’s going to cost you more than if you make smarter bets.

Could it pay off? Maybe. 

But probably not.

A manual bidding strategy lets you monitor your CPC more closely and right down to the keyword.

5. You just aren’t fully in control

Listen, we have to be control freaks about our campaigns.

Our clients trust us to take care of their accounts and their money. We aren’t always working with big-budget clients who can afford to pay a little more on bids. We need to carefully monitor our clients’ accounts and bids, so we don’t blow their month’s budget on one keyword that isn’t even their most important one.

Needing and wanting to be in control is only one of the reasons we’re so good at our jobs. We also wouldn’t want to go back to a client and say “the algorithm is why you have to pay so much this month for only a couple of clicks.” 

We prefer to tell them that our optimized manual bidding strategies are why they got so many conversions this month.

It’s not evil, just limited

Automated bidding strategies aren’t terrible, but they are limited. Just like you can’t fully automate a factory without a human to monitor the machines, you can’t set your automated bids and then walk away whistling.

Even automated bids need to be adjusted by a human periodically, so don’t think you can avoid altering your bids altogether if you choose the automatic route.

If you want to move away from automated bidding to a manual bidding approach, but you aren’t sure if you can do it yourself, then you know where to find the experienced team at Digital Strike. Drop us a line! We can help you optimize your campaigns and grow your business.

Digital Strike

Learn more about Digital Strike

Recent Posts

Ready, Set, Send! 15 Best Email Newsletter Marketing Practices

It’s hard to overstate the importance of a robust email marketing strategy in the digital marketing world. For small businesses and mega corporations alike, email newsletters … Read More

TikTok for Business - a woman excitedly looks at a camera. Pink background. Digital Strike - Targeted Marketing logo in the bottom left-hand corner.

Use TikTok for Business Like a #Pro

Social media marketing is one of the best ways to make sales; according to one study, 80% of consumers made a purchase as a result of … Read More

All About the Click-Through Rate – CTR Explained

You need benchmarks to determine the success of your paid ad campaigns. One such metric? Click-through rate, otherwise known as CTR. At a glance, CTR can … Read More

Understanding User Intent (Without a Psychology Degree)

Life is often one big mystery, but figuring out what customers and search users are really looking for doesn’t have to be mysterious at all. And … Read More

Share of Search: What Is It and How Can Digital Marketers Use It?

As all marketers know, there is no crystal ball, psychic, or voodoo witch doctor that can help us predict the future…but we do have magic on … Read More

Digital Marketing Skills – What Soft Skills You Need (and Why)

Data analytics. Copywriting. Content creation. SEO. These quantifiable analytical skills are all necessary for a strong digital marketing team. But what about the soft skills you … Read More

Does Alexa Spy on You? Here’s How Voice Data Is Used to Target You With Ads

According to a new report: Yes, Alexa is spying on you…and yes, listening to you is the reason you may be getting those uncomfortably specific ads. … Read More

Google and Bing Search Partner Spam List 2022

UPDATED GOOGLE SPREADSHEET – CLICK HERE  *Last updated 1/11/2022 As Google moves to automate more and more within their paid search platform, it becomes harder to … Read More

Paid Search Metrics That Matter – Demystifying PPC Campaigns

You’ve done your research and launched your pay-per-click (PPC) campaign. You have all the data points in the world to measure its success. But if you … Read More

How to Drive Traffic To Your Site

Everybody Asks: How to Drive Traffic To Your Site But nobody asks how your site is doing. (Doing great, thanks for asking!) All jokes aside, online … Read More

Google Core Web Vitals: What They Are & When They’ll Take Effect

Benjamin Franklin once said that the only guarantees in life are death and taxes. Maybe it’s time we add Google updates to that list. If you’re … Read More

lead-generation

How CMOs Can Take Back Their Brand From Lead Generation Sites

Other Websites Stealing Your Leads? If you’re responsible for overseeing the marketing initiatives for a business, especially in the senior living industry, you’ve probably encountered the … Read More

Lead Source Attribution Modeling

Take Back Your Leads & Revenue: How Lead Source Attribution Can Reveal Lost Online Opportunities We’ve had the distinct pleasure of speaking to or working with … Read More

B2B Digital Marketing

Whether you’re happy with your current marketing agency, haven’t worked with one, or anywhere in between, these are the characteristics that separate the exceptional agencies from the rest.

digital strike building

Why you should reconsider cutting marketing costs during coronavirus pandemic

The coronavirus pandemic has deeply affected hundreds of millions of people across the world. Our daily routines have been disrupted, and businesses of all sizes are … Read More

Top Stories of 2019

The year is quickly coming to a close, and it seems just like yesterday that we were welcoming 2019. The world of digital marketing is constantly … Read More

5 Reasons To Advertise on YouTube

If you aren't advertising on YouTube, you might be missing out.

11 Things Your Website Is Missing (and 6 Things to Get Rid of)

We've come a long way from the early days of the internet. Here's how to make sure your website looks like it was made this year.

Getting the Most Out of Your Mobile App Engagement Campaigns


Make your Facebook app campaigns even better.

YouTube app

3 Types of YouTube Audience Targeting You Should Be Using

Over a billion users come to YouTube every month to watch something that will educate or entertain them. And those users aren’t just millennials or gen … Read More

Online reviews

How to Reply to Not-So-Pleasant Online Reviews

Is there a right or wrong way to respond to bad reviews? Absolutely.

9 Common PPC Mistakes (and What to Do Instead)

New to Google ads? Our PPC expert, Tommy, breaks down the most common mistakes and how to fix them.

What To Look For When Choosing A Marketing Company In St. Louis

Whether you’re happy with your current marketing agency, haven’t worked with one, or anywhere in between, these are the characteristics that separate the exceptional agencies from the rest.

How Does Digital Marketing Fit Into Your Sales Funnel?

If you're still using the old sales funnel (or didn't even know there's a new one!), let us bring you up to speed.

analytics platform

Has Your Domain Authority Changed? Here’s Why

This algorithm might send unsuspecting marketers into a panic. Find out what's going on.

Why You Don’t Need to Hire a Vertical-Specific Agency

While a vertical-specific agency might seem like the answer to your marketing prayers, you might want to think twice.

Sales Funnel Tools

4 Unique Tools That Help Grow Your Sales Funnel

We're breaking down four tools we use every day.

Landing Page vs. Homepage: What's the Difference?

Landing Page vs. Homepage: What’s the Difference?

They’re the same thing, aren’t they? Just different names for the same thing, right? Wrong! Technically, while a visitor to your site can land on its … Read More

The No BS Guide to Conversion-Optimized Landing Pages

The No BS Guide to Conversion-Optimized Landing Pages

Landing page optimization is the process of creating a well-designed page for pay-per-click campaign (PPC) visitors by optimizing each element on the page to maximize the … Read More

How to Make Your Black Friday Marketing a Success [Checklist]

Black Friday and Cyber Monday are coming up, so that means money is about to be SPENT. It’s a stressful time for many store owners as … Read More

Digital Marketing Resources to Bookmark Right Now [2021 Update]

Every marketing strategy needs a little boost as time carries on. Nothing can work seamlessly forever, or else your business will remain stagnant. That’s why marketers … Read More

How to Boost Your Website Loading Time

Remember dial-up? Watching a two-minute YouTube video took thirty minutes because it took so freaking long to load. Nowadays, 47% of people expect pages to load … Read More

Using Customer Testimonials to Improve Your Credibility (With Examples)

Whether you’re in eCommerce or industrial manufacturing, establishing credibility is essential to your content marketing  There is a limited amount of brands that don’t need to … Read More

Beginner’s Guide to the Conversion Funnel

You’ve probably heard your marketing team talk about it all the time – The Customer Conversion Funnel. “It’s all about getting customers to go through the conversion funnel.” … Read More

How to Build Your Email List from Scratch

So you’ve decided to send out a newsletter or maybe we recommended you create one. But where do you begin? The key to any successful newsletter … Read More

The New Celebrity Endorsements: How Social Media Influencers Changed the Game

In the streaming mob of content that is consumed daily on the internet – from whatever people see at work to their social feeds – a … Read More

How to Use UTM Parameters

You already know that good marketers LOVE data. No, not that kind of Data (unless you’re a Trekkie and a marketer).  More like data from Google … Read More

Email Marketing Has a Fantastic ROI

HERE’S WHY EMAIL MARKETING ROI IS BETTER THAN ANY OTHER TACTIC

You want your marketing dollars to generate new leads and engage current customers, but you also need that strategy to be cost-effective. Email marketing is the … Read More

7 Easy Steps for a Foolproof Social Media Audit

One of the greatest (and sometimes the most frustrating) aspects of social media is the fact that it is always changing. And we’re not just talking … Read More

Why You Should Have a Blog

Why You Should Have a Blog

Creating unique content on your company’s website has benefits you haven’t considered yet. Do you want people to keep coming to your website? Are you working … Read More

digital strike building

How We Approach Problem Solving [Case Study]

Client A is a nationwide telecommunications company. They provide TV, internet, and phone services to customers across the country, primarily in Arizona, Arkansas, California, Louisiana, Missouri, … Read More

Does PPC Affect Organic Rankings?

A Digital Marketing Misconception: Does PPC Affect SEO?

In the digital marketing world, there are a lot of misconceptions and myths (myth-conceptions, if you will) about how organic search engine optimization and pay-per-click campaigns work together. We’ve heard and seen it all. … Read More

“How is HubSpot different from SEO?”: An honest answer to an actual client question

“Have you heard about inbound marketing?” This is how a recent client call started. Then, to make things worse, they proceeded to ask, “How is HubSpot … Read More

Why you aren’t ranking first in Google for [INSERT KEYWORD] … And why that’s okay

You might be wondering: “Why am I not ranking first in Google for [INSERT KEYWORD]?” It’s not a bad question—it shows you value your business’ position … Read More

Digital Strike Targeted Marketing

Reintroducing Digital Strike

You know the old saying, the cobbler’s children have no shoes? Well, for us it’s true. For a long time, we’ve been our own worst client. … Read More